How To Prove a Medical Malpractice Case in Pennsylvania

Discover the essential factors you must prove in a medical malpractice claim

How to prove a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania? If you or a loved one is a victim of medical malpractice, you know firsthand that unlocking justice in a medical malpractice case is no easy feat. It is like solving a complex puzzle where the road to accountability in healthcare negligence is paved with complicated legal requirements and rigorous standards of proof. 

But fear not since PA Malpractice Lawyers P.C. is here to guide you. We will explore the essential components that form the backbone of a successful medical malpractice claim. We’ll take you through the primary steps and provide crucial insights and guidance to champion your cause

Don’t let medical malpractice go unpunished. Let PA Malpractice Lawyers P.C. be your unwavering support in pursuing justice. Contact us today to schedule a free consultation.

What is Medical Malpractice?

Medical malpractice is a legal term that pertains to situations wherein a healthcare provider, including but not limited to doctors, nurses, hospitals, and other medical professionals, fails to provide the expected standard of care that a reasonably prudent individual would exhibit in comparable circumstances, resulting in harm or injury to a patient. 

What are Examples of Medical Negligence?

Medical malpractice encompasses a wide range of situations where a healthcare provider’s actions or omissions deviate from the accepted standard of care, resulting in harm or injury to a patient. Examples of medical negligence can include:

  • Misdiagnosis or Delayed Diagnosis
  • Surgical Errors
  • Medication Errors
  • Birth Injuries
  • Anesthesia Errors
  • Failure to Obtain Informed Consent
  • Nursing Home Neglect
  • Radiology and Laboratory Errors
  • Inadequate Follow-Up Care
  • Failure to Monitor
  • Psychiatric Malpractice
  • Dental Malpractice

Not every medical error constitutes medical negligence or medical malpractice. Consulting with our medical malpractice attorney can help evaluate the specifics of your situation and determine whether you have a valid claim.

How Can I Prove a Medical Malpractice Claim in Pennsylvania?

We understand that proving a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania can be daunting and complicated. We empathize with the challenges you may face in gathering evidence and meeting the fundamental legal requirements. Here’s a helpful guide on how to prove a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania:

Establish the Doctor-Patient Relationship

Establishing the existence of a doctor-patient relationship is a crucial first step in any medical malpractice case. This relationship forms the basis for the duty of care owed by the healthcare provider to the patient. The following evidence can help you establish the doctor-patient relationship:

  • Medical Records: Medical records often provide the most straightforward evidence of the doctor-patient relationship. Request copies of your medical records from the healthcare provider or facility where you received treatment. 
  • Billing Records: Billing records, such as invoices and statements, can also be evidence of the doctor-patient relationship. These records typically include details about the services provided, the healthcare provider’s name, and the patient’s name.
  • Prescriptions: If the healthcare provider prescribes medications or treatments for you, prescription records can further substantiate the doctor-patient relationship. 
  • Appointment Scheduling: Documentation of appointments and scheduling, such as appointment cards, confirmation emails, or phone records indicating appointments, can demonstrate that you sought and received care from the healthcare provider.
  • Witness Statements: In some cases, witnesses who were present during your interactions with the healthcare provider may be able to attest to the existence of the doctor-patient relationship.

Demonstrate Deviation from the Standard of Care

Establishing a deviation from the standard of care involves demonstrating that the healthcare provider’s actions or decisions fell below the accepted standard of care for their profession and that this deviation harmed the patient. Here’s how to establish a deviation from the standard of care:

  • Consult Medical Experts: One of the most critical steps in proving a deviation from the standard of care is consulting with medical experts. These experts, often fellow healthcare professionals with expertise in the relevant field, can provide valuable opinions on what should be the standard of care and whether the healthcare provider in question deviated from it.
  • Review Medical Guidelines and Literature: Medical experts rely on established medical guidelines, peer-reviewed literature, and best practices to determine the standard of care. Gather relevant medical guidelines and research articles about your medical condition or procedure. 
  • Gather Medical Records: Obtain copies of your medical records, including notes, test results, and treatment plans. These records can provide insights into the care you received and whether it deviated from the standard. Look for inconsistencies, errors, or omissions in those documents.
  • Interview Witnesses: Speak with any witnesses who were present during your medical treatment. They may have observed actions or decisions by the healthcare provider that could support your claim.

Establish Causation

Establishing causation in a medical malpractice case involves demonstrating that the healthcare provider’s deviation from the standard of care was the direct cause of the patient’s injuries or harm. To achieve this, here are the factors you need to demonstrate.

  • But-for Test: In many medical malpractice cases, the “but-for” test is used to establish causation. This test asks whether, but for the healthcare provider’s negligence, the patient’s injuries would have occurred. In other words, you need to prove that the harm would not have happened if the healthcare provider had adhered to the standard of care.
  • Chain of Events: Establish a definite chain of events that connects the healthcare provider’s actions or decisions to your injuries. That may require expert testimony to explain the medical cause-and-effect relationship. 
  • Examine Pre-existing Conditions: If you have pre-existing medical conditions, it is essential to differentiate between the harm caused by the healthcare provider’s actions and any pre-existing issues. Medical experts can help establish the extent to which the provider’s negligence contributed to your injuries, considering your overall health.
  • Documenting the Progression of Injuries: If your injuries or condition worsened following the healthcare provider’s negligence, ensure there is a clear record of this progression. Medical records, photographs, and expert testimony can help illustrate how the harm escalated due to the deviation from the standard of care.
  • Avoiding Other Potential Causes: Addressing and ruling out other potential causes of your injuries is critical. Determine whether any other factors, such as underlying medical conditions or unforeseen complications, played a role in your harm.

Document Damages

Documenting damages serves as the basis for seeking compensation for the harm you suffered. Documenting damages properly helps establish the extent of your losses and their connection to the healthcare provider’s negligence. Here’s how to document your damages in a medical malpractice case:

  • Medical Records: Obtain and retain copies of all relevant medical records that detail the nature and extent of your injuries, treatment plans, and any complications or adverse effects. That includes records of your initial treatment, subsequent care, surgeries, medications, diagnostic tests, and other medical expenses. 
  • Prescriptions and Medications: Keep records of all prescriptions and medications you have been prescribed from the malpractice. That includes the medication name, dosage, frequency, and the prescribing healthcare provider.
  • Medical Bills and Invoices: Retain all medical bills, invoices, and receipts of your treatment and recovery. That includes bills for doctor visits, hospital stays, surgeries, physical therapy, medications, medical equipment, and other healthcare expenses.
  • Photographic Evidence: If applicable, take photographs of your injuries or the aftermath of the malpractice. Visual documentation can provide compelling evidence of the physical harm you have suffered.
  • Pain and Symptom Journal: Maintain a detailed journal or diary documenting your pain, symptoms, and the impact of the malpractice on your daily life. Describe the severity and duration of pain, emotional distress, and how your injuries have affected your ability to work, perform daily activities, and enjoy life.
  • Lost Wages and Employment Records: If you have experienced lost income due to malpractice, keep records of your employment history, pay stubs, and any documentation that supports your claim for lost wages. That may also include correspondence with your employer regarding time off work.

What If I Don’t Have Complete Evidence To Prove Medical Negligence in Pennsylvania?

Medical malpractice claims hinge on the ability to establish negligence on the part of a healthcare provider. But what happens when you find yourself in a situation where the evidence to support your claim feels incomplete or insufficient? It is a scenario that many individuals facing the aftermath of medical errors may face.

While having comprehensive evidence is undoubtedly advantageous, it is not always a roadblock to seeking justice. Remember that obtaining the compensation and closure you deserve is still possible even when faced with incomplete evidence. Let’s explore strategies and considerations that can help you pursue a medical malpractice claim, even when the puzzle pieces seem elusive.

  • Consult an Attorney: Speak with our experienced medical malpractice attorney in Pennsylvania. We can assess the strength of your case based on the evidence you do have and provide guidance on whether it is worth pursuing. We can offer strategies for obtaining additional evidence or finding weaknesses in the healthcare provider’s defense.
  • Explore Discovery: The discovery phase of a lawsuit allows both parties to exchange information and gather evidence. We can use this process to request documents, records, and other evidence from the healthcare provider, which may uncover additional information to support your case.
  • Consult with Expert Witnesses: Expert witnesses can be instrumental in establishing the standard of care and deviations from it. We can help connect you with medical experts who can provide opinions based on the available evidence, helping to strengthen your case.
  • Consider Alternative Theories: While you may not have complete evidence to prove negligence in one way, there could be alternative theories or aspects of the case that can be explored. Our legal team can help you identify these and develop strategies to support your claim.
  • Negotiate a Settlement: In some cases, it may be possible to negotiate a settlement with the healthcare provider’s insurance company without going to trial. We can engage in settlement discussions based on the evidence you have, and provide guidance on whether a settlement offer is fair given the circumstances.

While having complete evidence is ideal, our experienced attorneys at PA Malpractice Lawyers P.C. can work with the evidence at hand to build a compelling case. Call us today to determine the best course of action for your situation.

How Long Do I Have to Sue for Medical Malpractice in PA?

A two-year statute of limitations applies for filing a medical malpractice lawsuit in Pennsylvania. Failure to adhere to the statute of limitations can result in your case being dismissed. It is also crucial to be aware of some possible exemptions that may be applicable to your case, including:  

  • Discovery Rule: If the injury was not immediately evident or could not have reasonably been discovered during the alleged medical malpractice.
  • Minority Tolling: If the injured party is a minor (under 18 years old), the statute of limitations is “tolled,” or paused, until their 18th birthday. 
  • Other Exceptions: For instance, if the healthcare provider who committed the malpractice leaves Pennsylvania before the statute of limitations expires, the deadline may be extended for up to two years.

If you believe you have a valid medical malpractice claim, consult with our medical malpractice attorney in Pennsylvania as soon as possible to ensure you meet the necessary deadlines and your rights are protected. 

Let Our Pennsylvania Medical Malpractice Attorney Help You Prove Your Case!

Do not let the legal complexities of proving a medical malpractice case in Pennsylvania scare you off. Sure, it can be challenging, especially when the evidence feels incomplete. But seeking justice for medical negligence is not impossible. You need to arm yourself with knowledge, consult with our medical malpractice lawyer, and explore all available avenues. 

Remember that every case is different, and the strength of your claim may change as new evidence becomes available or as you use legal strategies to strengthen it. That is why it is so crucial to have our experienced medical malpractice attorney at PA Malpractice Lawyers P.C. on your side.

Fight for your rights! Pursue a valid claim, hold negligent healthcare providers accountable, and seek the compensation you deserve for the harm you’ve suffered. And don’t forget to give us a call for a free consultation! 

Share this post:
Pennsylvania Medical Malpractice Attorney

Contact us completely free

You don't pay until we settle your claim

Sidebar Form